Forum › Pests & Disease

Oxalic dribble or a vaporiser for four hives in Kent — which would you buy, and what safety kit do I actually need?

Kent, third year, five colonies after the unite. My winter treatment has always been a dribble because that's what my mentor lent me, and a few people at the association are telling me I should buy a vaporiser instead. What I think I know. A dribble is a solution trickled between the frames while the colony is broodless; the kit is a syringe and a container, it's cheap, and I can do five hives in ten minutes without a battery. Vaporising drives the acid through the hive as a vapour; it needs a device, power, and the hive sealed for a few minutes, so it's slower per hive but reportedly kinder to the bees. My actual questions. For a hobbyist with five hives, is there any real benefit to the vaporiser, or is that a commercial tool I'd be buying for the fun of owning it? What safety equipment is genuinely necessary for each — I've got goggles and nitrile gloves and I assume vapour needs proper respiratory protection? Whichever it is, I'll be using a licensed product and following its label, so I'm asking about method and equipment rather than amounts.
#oxalic-acid#equipment#safety#winter-treatment
▲ 12 votes 💬 4 replies ✅ Solved
4 replies
ImkerinLena · Oct 19, 2026 · ✅ Accepted answer
Timing beats method every time, which is why your last paragraph matters more than the choice of kit. For five colonies a dribble is entirely adequate and thousands of beekeepers use nothing else. Safety: for a dribble, acid-resistant gloves, eye protection, and don't mix it in the kitchen. For vapour, you need proper respiratory protection rated for acid gas, not a dust mask, plus eye protection, and you must stand upwind. That difference alone answers it for most hobbyists.
PerthshireBees · Oct 19, 2026
Perthshire. I've used both. The vaporiser is better when you have thirty hives and a routine, because you're not opening anything and there's no liquid going onto bees in cold weather. At five hives the dribble wins on simplicity. Also check what's actually licensed where you are — in some countries only specific registered products may be used, and the label is the legal document, not the forum.
SkaneBees · Oct 19, 2026
Skåne. One practical point in favour of the dribble for a beginner: you can see what you've done. A vaporiser that isn't sealing properly or isn't reaching temperature can leave you thinking a hive has been treated when it hasn't, and you won't find out until March. KentishBee, whichever you choose, count the drop afterwards so you know it worked.
KentishBee · Oct 20, 2026
Sticking with the dribble then, and buying better gloves and a tray to mix in outdoors. Also going to do a proper seven-day tray count after, which I've never bothered with.
More in Pests & Disease

How long do mites survive in a dead-out, and is comb from a varroa collapse safe to give to another colony?

Skåne, eight years. I've got the boxes from a colony that collapsed in September sitting in my shed — properly diagnosed as far as I can tell, heavy mite load, deformed w…

SkaneBees · Skåne, SE · Pests & Disease · Oct 25, 2026 · ▲ 11 · 💬 4 · ✅ Solved

Velutina nest found 200 m from my apiary in late October — is destroying it this late still worth it, and who do I call?

Provence, eight years, sixteen hives. A neighbour clearing branches found a nest the size of a beach ball high in a plane tree at the edge of the village, and it's unmist…

LavenderSophie · Provence, FR · Pests & Disease · Oct 23, 2026 · ▲ 12 · 💬 4

Reading the tray debris in October — what do wax flakes, chewed cappings and pollen crumbs tell me about the cluster?

Vermont, second year. After the mess I made of not noticing a dying colony last month I've put clean trays under all three remaining hives, partly for mite counts and par…

VTBeeHannah · Vermont, US · Pests & Disease · Oct 21, 2026 · ▲ 10 · 💬 4 · ✅ Solved

No broodless window in southern Spain — is caging the queen to get a clean varroa treatment worth the risk?

Andalusia, ten years, 22 colonies. The northern threads about timing a treatment for the broodless period are lovely to read and completely inapplicable here. My colonies…

AbejasCarla · Andalusia, ES · Pests & Disease · Oct 18, 2026 · ▲ 11 · 💬 4

Late-October robbing at 24°C in Georgia — my entrance setup and how I spot the hive that's being stripped

Twenty-two years in middle Georgia, 40-odd colonies. October here isn't a wind-down, it's a knife fight. Days still hitting 24°C, nothing much coming in, and every colony…

GeorgiaWes · Georgia, US · Pests & Disease · Oct 16, 2026 · ▲ 12 · 💬 4

Pine honeydew still running in Muğla in October — how do you sequence mite control around a flow that ends in November?

Muğla, fifteen years, 60 colonies on pine. For anyone who doesn't know our system: the pine honeydew flow here runs from late summer into autumn, and in a good year we're…

muglabalci · Muğla, TR · Pests & Disease · Oct 13, 2026 · ▲ 11 · 💬 4

Join 12,000+ beekeepers logging hives, asking questions, and mapping forage.

Get the Beekeeping Community app